| Anime That
Sucks: Hanaukyo Maid-tai |
The Hanaukyo Maid Diaries
~by Chiriko
Disclaimer: I only plan on watching this shit
once. I am typing as I go along, because I refuse to subject myself to more of
this horrible crap.
A bit of poking around on the forums will
indeed show that our members have varying tastes and preferred styles both
inside and outside the animation world, and have, perhaps had more experience on
the FuKu side of things than they would prefer. As such, they often recommend to
me shows that, through some horrible misfortune or another, they have managed to
catch a glimpse of through some FuKu osmosis or review (or perhaps a randomly
suggested download to them by a particularly horrible person). I was assured by
one such FuKuteer (our old friend Hamster, I believe) that were I to stomach Hanaukyo
Maids (alternate titles: Maid in Hanaukyo, Hanaukyo Maid-tai),
I would have forever found the ultimate in incredibly nauseating stupid chauvinistic
harem-fantasy fanservice ani-shit. Boy, was she ever wrong; this show is far
worse than that.
Hanaukyo Maids follows the adventures of
some stupid whiny shota-brat named Hanaukyo Tarou who has come to his
grandfather's house after the death of his mother. After searching to find the
extremely large mansion, he is greeted by a stampede of obnoxious fanservice
maids, the first of which gives him a deep and extremely disturbing tongue-kiss.
Flash forward to the opening theme, singing
about "serving you with all our love." It just ended, and I'm
positively horrified. This is quite possibly the worst show of any media I have
ever seen in my entire life. I knew this shit would be bad, but ye gods!
This primordial ooze has no place in the world of civilized people.

I wish I could say I was taking this picture out of context. |
*sigh* What traces of journalistic integrity I
have require that I continue. The first scene of the movie reveals that the
boy's grandfather has left him a film (filled with more shots of the naked
breast in two minutes than in all of David Lynch's Mulholland Drive, but
without any legitimate artistic purpose) explaining, supposedly, why the hot
maid french-kissed him on his arrival. So, the kid finds out his grandfather has
moved to Fanservice Island and therefore the entire mansion is his, with his
immense staff of "maids" (read: slaves who derive nothing but pure
pleasure from serving their dear male master) and all his assets. Oh, god, I
knew this was going to be bad, but I never knew it would be this god-awful.
|

Deru! Deru zo!
出る!
出るぞ!!
|
So, then, the kid goes to the bathroom to take
a piss, and three attractive maids unzip his pants and insist that their old
master made them do this. So, the kid is struggling with them, screams "deru!
deru zo!" which is um... bad. =P Trust me on that one. At any rate, he
pisses himself and then has an argument with them over whether they can
remove/change his clothes or not. So, to recap, you have twentysomething maids
poking around and giving themselves to complete sexual and literal servitude to
a sixth-grader who doesn't even want it. Isn't that called "statutory
rape" in the Real World?
It gets worse. Far, far worse. He goes to the
private hot spring at the mansion and expresses how nice it is to finally be
alone. (OH NO! I THINK I KNOW WHERE THIS IS GOING!!! =P) Minute nine of this
crap and the shota-boy is HAVING HIMSELF WASHED BY THE LATHERED BREASTS OF A
HUNDRED NAKED MAIDS!!!
|

OH THE WACKY HIJINKS!!!
|
The boy passes out or something and wakes up in
the lap of Mariel, the only maid he has a boner for (or, in my opinion, a
mother-complex... *shudder*). In this telling scene, he reveals that he's not
really sure whether he likes this or not. Which essentially shows the most
chilling fact of all; he's not against being served in every way by a harem of
live-in sex-slaves in maid costumes on any sort of "women are people"
grounds, he's just a big fucking pussy and that's why this makes him
uncomfortable. It's as if every character in Tenchi Muyo went out of
their way to blow Tenchi and wash him with their breasts, except Tenchi would
have to be in sixth grade. Damn this show!!!!! Predictably, as Mariel leaves him
to go to bed, three adult women hop into bed with him and insist on
"pleasing him for the final time of the day." The lights go dark. The
holocaust is complete.
...Or so you'd think! No, the ending theme
features three incredibly ugly Japanese women in maid costumes!
|

Note the extraordinary artistic detail in drawing our attention to the
subject through the use of primary colors. (The subject is fellating
underage boys.)
|
At the start of the second episode, before the
abominable credits even begin to roll, three maids hop into bed with Tarou and fellate
him to consciousness. I am not even joking. You don't actually SEE the cock
being sucked, but there is absolutely NO way this scene means anything else.
Don't give me those innocent slapstick gestures and tell me three adult women
weren't just fellating an underage boy to climax, otaku. There are no other
possibilities! This scene is unambiguous! Oh god, I think the second episode
will be the end of me.
Now the kid is going to school in a helicopter.
(I'm counting the seconds before something stupid happens.) After exactly 37
seconds of actual dialogue (a new record!!!) we see that the back is filled with
maids in seifuku ready to serve him at school as well. Hoo boy. Then Mariel
attaches another flimsy attempt at plot to this stupid show by saying that any
maids who don't do their work have to be laid off. We see one of the whiny maids
being fired and having to take a sleazy life as a porn star in Tarou's fantasy,
so of course he can't fire them.
He gets surrounded by the maid schoolgirls in
his new class (how suspicious), and then the teacher calls him up to the front
of the class to do a math problem. Rather than exercise his knowledge of the
quadratic formula, he's about to piss himself, so the maids do something
implausible to scribble the right answers on the board, which gets his teacher
gushing over him. So, let's review: the kid is misogynistic, annoying, whiny, and
stupid.
Add "bad at sports" to that list and
you have the next fucking section of this crime against humanity. The
maids-cum-students chat up with the real high school girls about how cool that
new boy is (but not without a gratuitous locker room scene), at which point the
show crosses over from disturbingly insane to repulsively insane. The maids use
an implausible rope-and-pulley system to help him be the basketball star so that
all the high school girls will want to sleep with him.
|

See, this is the fate of attractive and intelligent specialist women in
Japan if they can't be sex slaves to rich brats!
|
The third episode (already featuring more
undocumented stupidity) gives us the introduction of the incredibly stupid
frilly shirt of the rich kid and the lolicon maid. Thank god. I was about to say
"man, there just isn't enough pedophilia in this show!" Glad they gave
me an eight-year-old girl too. Then we meet the inventor girl that Tarou
pictured being a porn star earlier. Turns out she's a scientific genius who
invents incredible life-changing devices. And she's working as a sex slave to a
brat. Oh, guess what? She also loves anime. So you have a brilliant but
subservient hot girl with glasses who loves anime. I apologize to the creators
of Love Hina and I My Me Strawberry Eggs for calling their
programs "purely unforgivable fanservice with no redeeming story
whatsoever." Which those programs are. But there's no way to emphasize
exactly how horrible this show is. Love Hina has the character depth,
directional expertise, and fascinating story of Cowboy Bebop or Boogiepop
when compared with this fucking god-awful show.
Oh, got off on a bit of a tangent there. Third
episode. Well, basically, the nerd maid builds a machine to change the weather
that blows up and destroys the house, but Tarou saves everyone. Their lives are
in jeopardy, but thankfully there is still time for some stupid panty shots. As
if to reward the viewer for having to sit through what (although incredibly
stupid) was actually a story instead of gratuitous plotless fanservice, the end
of this episode features mysteriously (and unexplained) dissolving clothes (yes,
even on the little girl, though she's wearing a slip underneath) and a sudden
snowstorm as the house explodes, followed by a topless snowball fight.
That's right. A topless snowball fight. My
horror knows no limits.
The fourth episode attempts to establish even
more story to this stupid crap by introducing the rival of the House of Hanaukyo,
the heiress to some other stupid rich family. She has a staff of attractive
males wearing open shirts. She comes and bitches at Tarou about somethingorother,
then he accidentally hits her with a giant steel girder on the forehead, and she
bleeds fountains of blood all over the place. Blood is literally spurting
from her forehead. Then the nerdy maid finds and disassembles her blimp for
materials, and the three fellatio maids show up again demanding their turn at
giving him "service." Did I mention this is the worst show I've ever
seen?
|

Here to serve serve serve you!
|
Let me assure each and every one of my readers
right here and right now that this is not a show any sane Japanese person would
watch, just as it is not a show any sane non-Japanese person would watch. The
creators are otaku. The target market is otaku. Hell, even the characters are
otaku. And in that way, this show is far more deranged than anything "otakish"
that might have a slight chance of making its way to the semi-mainstream (like
Love Hina). This show is a sexist realization of complete and unabashed
male-dominance fantasy. In otherwords, Hanaukyo Maids is pure fucking
unabashed pornography, but without any of the sex scenes. Now, why would you
want to watch, own, or collect crap related to a show that was pornography
masquerading as a mainstream program? This is far more dangerous and disturbing
than actual pornography, because we know actual porn's function. You expect
pornography (anime or real-life) to be really bad; you expect explicit sex. You
know damn well that that's the point, and that's why porn is enjoyable to many
people on an ironic (it's fucking stupid and funny) and unironic (people
are, after all, fucking) way. Hanaukyo Maids fails to be funny or
enjoyable on either one of these levels; I can't understand why the otaku who
masturbates to La Blue Girl and Urotsukidoji would enjoy this.
|

These three ugly women have set the women's movement in Japan back fifty
years.
|
To put it bluntly: This show has no redeeming
qualities for any aspect of any society, and I mean that from the bottom of my
heart. It is a despicable, lamentable, and laughable attempt at creating a
plausible form of media-based entertainment from a sexual fantasy and an
unrealistic approach towards the opposite sex. More disturbingly, though, it is
pornography masquerading as legitimate theater; it is one step short of actual
pornography and five or six steps too far beyond stupid fanservice crap. And
while it is certainly not the only show that is not-quite-explicit enough to be
porn but also not quite interesting or story-driven enough to be, well,
enjoyable (think Demon Hunter Yoko), it is by far the absolute worst of
its kind.
I do not joke when I say this, as I often do;
this time, I mean what I say from the bottom of the depths of what was once my
heart but is now a pit fillled with inhuman rage and contempt for all mankind as
a result of sitting through four episodes of Hanaukyo Maids: This
is the worst show of any film-based media, anime or otherwise, that I have ever
seen in my life.
In searching for other opinions and information
on this show in the wonderful garden of the internet I have come across sites
which have given this show good ratings, proudly advertising it as a legitimate,
if not slightly "ecchi," anime. The average user-rating of this show
at animenfo.com, for example, was 7.2/10, averaged from 84 reviews.
I have invented a rating system (a concept I
initially shied away from for this site) to be applied to all of the reviews
done thus far on this website (check the other reviews for newly-added ratings),
just so I can express how completely abominable this show is in a numeric
format, just to drive the point home one last time. To fully emphasize how
horrible this show is, I am allowing for negative scores despite this being a
positive-integer based system.
|
Hanaukyo Maid-tai |
| Category |
Comments |
Rating |
| Animation/Art |
This show features the most
spectacularly detailed naked breasts I have ever seen in anime. Looking
at the art and animation from a purely aesthetic stance, it's no Studio
Ghibli, but by no means is it sloppily thrown together. That makes this
all even sadder for me; to think, months of detailed production went
into something this awful.
Luckily, they didn't really bother to
animate (or change the expression of) the little shota boy at all, so I
have a pretty good reason to give them a bad score. However, due
to the immense detail of the nipples in this show, I can't give it that
bad a score. :( |
-2 / 10 |
| Music |
I'm pretty harsh on most
anime music, but I also have sympathy for commercial composers, being a
composer myself (and more specifically one who aims to work commercially
in the film and TV industry). I understand there are limitations. But
there are not reasons to write music this bad, even for a show this bad.
However, were I the composer working on
a project like this, I must honestly say I would not have invested any
effort into this waste of time. Nonetheless, the music only makes this
horrible crap even more obnoxious than it already is.
Also, the theme songs are among the
worst songs ever written, produced, sung, and recorded in the history of
all music. And this is anime music we're talking about, too. |
-10 / 10 |
| Story |
It's basically the same
quality of plot you'd expect from a porn movie, but without any
[explicit] sex. |
-25 / 25 |
| Direction |
The director's name is
apparently Yasuki Ide, and his only involvement in anime has been with
this awful show. I suspect the name is made up to protect his actual
career, or this is a newbie breaking into the industry by way of
softcore porn. Regardless, I can
almost assure you he is not married. I cannot give any director
validation (even with a story as bad as this) for semi-decent dramatic
techniques when every scene is an excuse for another panty shot or
full-out seventy-naked-tit panorama. If I ever see the name 'Yasuki Ide'
attached to another piece of animation I will remember this show with vengeance
in my heart. |
-25 / 25 |
| Characters |
The main characters consist
of a stupid misogynistic boy and a thousand subservient and practically
identical sex slaves in maid costumes. There's also the transparent
"rival" character. There's nothing redeeming about any of the
characters in this show. They have no depth. I want them to die. |
-10 / 10 |
| Acting |
I don't have a lot of regard
for seiyuu to begin with, but it's hard to voice-act, especially when
you have nothing to work with (read: the dialogue in this show). With
that said, the acting is hardly anything more than overblown stereotype
anime character-acting or pornlike moans and groans. |
-5 / 10 |
| Replay Value |
Have you ever seen something
that made you feel less than human for watching it? That is Hanaukyo
Maids in a nutshell. If I ever have to watch this show again I will
stab someone to death. |
-60 / 10 |
| Total |
This show is a full two
hundred and thirty-seven points beneath what could be considered good
animation. |
-137 / 100 |
|